Smartphone Repairability Showdown: Google Pixel Surpasses iPhone and Samsung

Daily Technology

09/04/2026

A recent report from the US Public Interest Research Group (PIRG) has evaluated the repairability of smartphones from the top manufacturers in the United States, revealing that while there is significant room for improvement across the board, Google's Pixel devices hold an edge over competitors from Apple and Samsung.

The study, titled “Failing the Fix (2026),” serves as an industry benchmark, aiming to encourage manufacturers to design more sustainable and easily repairable products for consumers.

The Repairability Rankings

The report assigns letter grades to each brand based on a comprehensive scoring system. The results place Motorola at the top of the list, with Google trailing but still outperforming its primary rivals.

Motorola: B+
Google Pixel: C-
Samsung: D
Apple: D-

These scores indicate that while Motorola leads the pack, the overall performance of the industry's biggest players is underwhelming. Google's C- grade, while not exceptional, positions it ahead of Samsung and notably above Apple, which received the lowest score among the four brands evaluated.

Understanding the Scoring Criteria

The rankings are derived from data published in the European Union’s European Product Registry for Energy Labelling. The evaluation is not based on a single factor but a weighted combination of several key metrics. A significant emphasis is placed on the ease of disassembly, which is a critical first step in any repair.

Other contributing factors include the availability of official documentation and spare parts for consumers and independent repair shops. The report also considers the longevity of software support, rewarding manufacturers who provide updates for an extended period. This multi-faceted approach provides a holistic view of each brand's commitment to repairability.

Industry Implications and Outlook

The publication of these scores is intended to apply public pressure on manufacturers to enhance their product design and support policies. By highlighting deficiencies, the report advocates for a future where devices are less disposable.

Google has shown some initiative in this area beyond its smartphones. For instance, the Pixel Watch 4 was designed to be fully repairable, and the Pixel Buds 2a feature a replaceable battery in their case—a rarity in the true wireless earbud market. These developments suggest a growing awareness within the company of the importance of repairability, even as its smartphone scores indicate more progress is needed.

2026-04-01

The Future in Focus: Key Tech Trends from Early 2026

Explore the defining tech trends of early 2026. From affordable high-performance laptops to open-ear audio and design-led mid-range phones, see what's next.